Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)
By Vince Palmere
Lately there has been a lot of talk about VOCs and how they relate to products used on log homes. Rather than try to explain them in an article we’ve taken some of the most frequently asked questions that we have received and addressed them individually.
What are VOCs, and what are the risks posed by VOCs to the environment?
VOCs are Volatile Organic Compounds, typically petroleum based solvents and other liquids contained in coatings, sealants, cleaners, fuels and other products that evaporate into the atmosphere. Once in their vapor state they have been implicated in both the reduction of the ozone layer and contributing to the green-house effect. In addition, many of these compounds are designated as health hazards. VOCs are typically measured in terms of grams per liter (g/L). If you look on a can of oil-based paint or stain you will see the VOC content range between 150 grams per liter and 550 grams per liter. The higher the number, the more VOCs are contained in the product.
What are some of the VOC restrictions placed on stains?
Stains are classified as architectural coatings and both state and federal agencies have limited the amount of VOCs allowed in architectural coatings. Some states like California, Virginia, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and others have placed VOC limits lower than those mandated by the Federal government which is why many oil-based stains are no longer allowed to be sold in these states. Within the next few years it is expected that both state and federal allowable VOC limits will continue to decrease.
What kind of challenges have the VOC restrictions posed to Perma-Chink Systems?
Since Perma-Chink Systems manufactures and sells only water-based coatings, VOC restrictions have not had much of an impact on us other than increasing the demand for our products. However, there is one method of measuring VOCs that could possibly have a minor impact.
Back when VOCs first became an issue the solvent-based coating manufacturers got together to lobby that it was unfair to compare a water-based coating system with a solvent-based system. The result was a method of determining the VOC content of water-based products by first removing all of the water. Even if a product contained 90% water, this method only looked at the remaining 10% of the components. Although this method of determining VOCs in water-based coatings has fallen out of favor by many regulating agencies, it is still used by some of the states.
All of our products currently meet the VOC requirements for all 50 states plus Canada. However, when developing new products we must keep in mind all methods of measuring the VOC content of the product.
Is there any difference in the quality, color and durability of low VOC water-based stains versus oil-based stains?
Over the past few years almost all new innovations in coating technology have been in low VOC water-based systems. This new technology has allowed the development of high quality products like our LIFELINE brand stains and Advance Topcoats that not only look great but meet all of the requirements of a log home.
Recent advances in polymers, UV light inhibitors and mildewcides have significantly improved the look, longevity and performance of water-based coating systems. For those manufacturers like Perma-Chink Systems willing to make the investment, this new technology has allowed us to develop water-based products that look better, last longer and outperform the best oil-based product ever made.
On the other hand, one way that high VOC oil-based coating manufacturers have lowered their VOC content is to add fillers such as calcium carbonate to their coatings. The subsequent reduction in solvent content has, in most cases, decreased the attractiveness and performance of these products.
Why is it important for Perma-Chink Systems to offer low-VOC products to your customers?
Since our inception back in 1981 Perma-Chink Systems has always had a concern for our environment and we have always taken the environmental impact of a product into consideration during its development. In retrospect this was and is a very wise decision which has resulted in our considerable growth over the years as people become more aware of their influence on the quality of our environment.
Aside from the environmental impact, are water-based products safer to use and apply?
Most water-based coatings have little if any odor and can be applied both inside and outside a home without concern. In addition, water-based coatings can be cleaned from brushes and spray equipment with just soap and water. On the other hand, oil-based coatings must be cleaned with mineral spirits which releases even more VOCs into the atmosphere.
If I’m used to using oil-based stains, what differences will I see applying your LIFELINE water-based products?
It really depends on what oil-based product you have used. The biggest difference you will initially notice is that when applying LIFELINE stains it is not nearly as important that the wood be absolutely dry. Most oil-based products require a wood moisture content of less than 18% before application. Since LIFELINE stains allow water vapor to escape from the wood, they can be applied to fairly green logs without a problem. Another difference is the application rate.
LIFELINE stains and topcoats are designed to be applied in thin coats, typically 350 to 600 square feet per gallon. Most oil-based products require an application rate of 150 to 250 square feet per gallon. So even though the cost of LIFELINE may initially appear to be higher than an oil-based stain the difference in application rate will more than make up the price difference when figuring out the total cost of the job.
Besides low-VOC water-based stains does Perma-Chink Systems make other earth-friendly products?
In addition to our stains, Perma-Chink Systems offers a wide range of sealants including Perma-Chink, Energy Seal, Stack-n-Seal, Check Mate, QSL and others. All of our sealants are low VOC water-based products. We do not make any oil-based products.
One of the biggest impacts Perma-Chink Systems has made in removing toxic materials from our environment was introducing borate wood preservatives to the log home industry. For those unfamiliar with borates, they are composed of borax and boric acid, the same compounds found in eye wash solutions and laundry additives. Fortunately, although they are quite low in toxicity to humans and animals, they are quite effective in eliminating and preventing insect and decay infestations in wood.
Prior to 1989 the only products available to prevent infestations of wood boring beetles, termites and decay in existing log homes were highly toxic, carcinogenic or corrosive. Perma-Chink Systems changed that by developing the first usable borate system that could be applied in the field. Although initially developed for log homes, this technology soon spread to other industries as well and today there are literally millions of log and traditionally built homes protected with the borate technology invented by Perma-Chink Systems. We currently offer four borate-based wood preservatives, Shell-Guard Concentrate, Shell-Guard RTU, Armor-Guard and Cobra Rods.